On this page
- Verdict
- Side-by-side comparison
- About Bright Data
- About Shifter
- Pricing compared
- Performance compared
- Pool & coverage
- Features face-off
- Trials & support
- Where Bright Data wins
- Where Shifter wins
- Bright Data pros & cons
- Shifter pros & cons
- Consider the alternative
- Switching between them
- Comparison FAQ
- Related comparisons
- Full reviews
- Related searches
- Make the call
Verdict
Bright Data wins this matchup. It ranks #2 to Shifter’s #14 in our weighted benchmark, pairing massive 72m+ residential pool with stronger overall scores. Shifter still makes sense where unlimited bandwidth on port plans is the deciding factor.
Side-by-side comparison
| Criterion | Bright Data | Shifter |
|---|---|---|
| Our rank | #2 of 15 | #14 of 15 |
| Rating | 4.6/5 | 3.8/5 |
| Entry price | $4.20/GB | ~$1.25/GB eq. |
| IP pool | 72M+ | 31M+ |
| Success rate | 98.9% | 93.8% |
| Proxy types | 4 | 2 |
| Free trial | Yes | — |
| City targeting | Yes | Country-level |
| Support | 24/7 with dedicated account managers | Tickets |
About Bright Data
Bright Data is the heavyweight of the industry, wrapping an enormous network in compliance tooling and unblocking tech that big corporations are happy to pay a premium for.
It pioneered much of the modern residential proxy model and has since layered scraping browsers, dataset products and strict KYC on top of its core network.
About Shifter
Shifter is the veteran of backconnect rotation, selling unlimited-bandwidth ports that reward heavy rotators willing to manage their own quality control.
One of the oldest names in rotating residential proxies, it kept its per-port pricing model long after most rivals moved to per-GB billing.
Pricing compared
Bright Data starts at $4.20/GB against Shifter’s ~$1.25/GB eq.. Raw stickers favour Shifter, but success rates adjust the picture: at 98.9% vs 93.8%, effective cost per successful request narrows the headline difference.
Performance compared
Speed indexes land at 95 (Bright Data) vs 70 (Shifter) in our 100-point scale; pools of 72M+ and 31M+ respectively shape how each absorbs concurrency. For sustained high-volume work, Bright Data has the steadier ceiling.
Pool & coverage
Coverage: 72M+ (Bright Data) vs 31M+ (Shifter). For geo-sensitive work note that city targeting is only on Bright Data.
Features face-off
Bright Data: Web Unlocker and scraping browser products; Industry-leading compliance and KYC controls.
Shifter: Large legacy IP network; Built for heavy rotation.
Trials & support
Bright Data support: 24/7 with dedicated account managers; trial: yes. Shifter support: Tickets; trial: no. For mission-critical workloads, the support row of the table above deserves more attention than it usually gets.
Where Bright Data wins
- You are large enterprises with compliance requirements and big budgets.
- Web Unlocker and scraping browser products.
- Industry-leading compliance and KYC controls.
Where Shifter wins
- You are rotation-heavy tasks priced by port rather than data.
- Built for heavy rotation.
- Large legacy IP network.
Bright Data pros & cons
- ✅ Massive 72M+ residential pool
- ✅ Web Unlocker and scraping browser products
- ✅ Industry-leading compliance and KYC controls
- ⚠️ Among the priciest options per GB
- ⚠️ Onboarding and KYC take real effort
Shifter pros & cons
- ✅ Unlimited bandwidth on port plans
- ✅ Large legacy IP network
- ✅ Built for heavy rotation
- ⚠️ Per-port costs add up quickly
- ⚠️ Performance can be inconsistent
Consider the alternative
Before settling this matchup, price in our overall #1: Cheapest Proxies undercuts both ($0.80/GB) while posting a 99.4% success rate — the highest of the fifteen networks we benchmark.
Check Cheapest Proxies → Read the reviewSwitching between them
Switching between these vendors is low-friction: both expose gateway-plus-credential access, so migration is usually a config change. Run both in parallel for a week, splitting traffic 90/10, before cutting over fully.
Comparison FAQ
Can I use both Bright Data and Shifter together?
Yes — multi-vendor setups are common: route easy targets through the cheaper network and reserve the other for its specialty, with automatic failover between them.
Which has the bigger pool, Bright Data or Shifter?
Bright Data — 72M+ versus 31M+. Pool size matters most for high-concurrency rotation.
Which is better, Bright Data or Shifter?
Bright Data wins our weighted benchmark (#2 vs #14), combining massive 72m+ residential pool with stronger value scores. Shifter remains the right call when rotation-heavy tasks priced by port rather than data matches your situation.
Do Bright Data and Shifter offer free trials?
Bright Data: yes. Shifter: no. Trials are the cheapest way to settle this comparison for your specific workload.
Is Bright Data cheaper than Shifter?
Entry pricing: $4.20/GB vs ~$1.25/GB eq.. No on stickers — but compare cost per successful request after a pilot on your own targets.
Full reviews
Deep-dive both sides: Bright Data review · Shifter review — or browse all 15 provider reviews.
Related searches
Make the call
Get premium proxies at the lowest price we found
Residential, ISP, datacenter and mobile IPs under one dashboard, from $0.80/GB, with no contracts and 24/7 support.